Marketing Automation Learning Centre.

Learn more about marketing automation and related services.

Why 80% of Broker Leads Don’t Convert (And How Automation Fixes It)

December 15, 2025•4 min read

Introduction

Across the finance industry, brokers regularly generate leads from advertising, referral partners, websites, marketplaces and social platforms. Yet despite the effort and investment required to attract these leads, the overwhelming majority never convert. In most brokerages, only 10–20% of leads become funded deals. The remaining 80–90% either go cold, never respond or delay long enough that the opportunity disappears entirely.

This is not a marketing problem—it is a timing and follow-up problem.

Borrowers today are busy, distracted and not always ready to proceed immediately. Many make an enquiry before they have their documents ready. Others enquire while researching multiple options. Some change jobs, shift priorities or simply forget. And then there are those who cannot be contacted despite multiple attempts.

Because of these dynamics, brokers relying on manual follow-up lose more opportunities than they close. Meanwhile, brokers using automation convert significantly more deals, with less effort and better client experience.

This article explains the causes of the conversion gap, what happens to leads inside a typical brokerage, and how automation transforms lead management into a predictable, scalable workflow.

1. The Real Reason Leads Don't Convert

Most brokers assume low conversion rates come from:

Low-quality leads
Bad marketing
Poor targeting
Unqualified consumers

While these can contribute, they are rarely the actual cause.

The truth is simple:

Most leads don’t convert because the timing isn’t right for the borrower at the moment they enquire.

Common examples include:

They need to find an asset
They are comparing options
They didn’t expect a call immediately
They are at work
They are unsure about affordability
They have paperwork to gather
They don’t yet trust the broker
They intend to respond later and forget

This timing mismatch means you need a system that maintains contact long enough for the borrower to become ready.

2. Timing + Speed-to-Lead

Speed is critical. If a broker takes too long to respond, the borrower moves on. The data across multiple industries is consistent: the broker who responds fastest almost always wins the enquiry.

But speed alone is not enough.

Even when responding quickly:

Around half of leads don’t answer the phone
Many don’t read emails
Some respond days later
Some open messages but do nothing
Some require multiple nudges

This means the follow-up system must be multi-channel, persistent and automated.

3. What Happens to Leads Inside Most Brokerages

When we review brokerage workflows, the same pattern appears:

Day 1–2:

Broker calls 1–3 times, sends one SMS.

Day 3–5:

Broker gets busy with live deals and stops chasing the lead.

Day 7 onward:

Lead is now cold.
If they respond, it's a surprise.
If they do not, they are abandoned.

This is the moment most brokerages lose the bulk of their potential revenue.

And then—weeks or months later—the borrower settles elsewhere, often at a lower rate or with another broker who simply followed up persistently.

4. How Automation Fixes the Conversion Problem

Automation creates a long-term, multi-channel engagement system that keeps the borrower moving toward a decision without relying on manual effort.

Key components include:

1. Immediate response automation

The system sends:

SMS
Email
Internal alert
Optional voicemail drop
Chatbot engagement

This ensures the borrower receives contact instantly, improving engagement while freeing the broker from reactive workload.

2. Intelligent multi-touch nurturing

Instead of stopping follow-up after 2–3 attempts, automation continues for days, weeks and months depending on the borrower’s behaviour.

This includes:

Follow-up SMS
Email pathways
Re-engagement messages
“Still looking?” nudges
Soft qualification prompts

3. Behaviour-based workflows

Automation varies based on actions:

Opened email
Clicked link
Replied via SMS
Submitted documents
Booked a call
Went silent

This recreates human judgement at scale.

4. Branching logic for consumer vs commercial

Commercial borrowers respond differently to consumer borrowers. Automation adapts messaging accordingly, increasing relevance and conversion rates.

5. Long-term nurture sequences

Many borrowers return months later when circumstances improve. Automation ensures they are not forgotten.

This includes:

Credit rebuild pathways
Debt consolidation nudges
Anniversary check-ins
“Ready to review again?” prompts

These pathways often recover deals that brokers assumed were lost.

5. The Compounding Effect of Automated Follow-Up

When brokers move from manual follow-up to automation, several changes occur:

Higher Contact Rates

Borrowers respond to SMS at far higher rates than email. Automated multi-channel contact increases the odds of connecting dramatically.

More Confidence for Borrowers

Consistent communication builds trust. Borrowers feel looked after and more organised.

Lower Workload for Brokers

Brokers spend less time chasing leads and more time on applications.

Higher Settlements Without Increasing Leads

Better follow-up means more deals from the same volume of leads.

In most cases, settlement increases of 20–40% occur without needing to spend more on advertising.

6. Why Brokers Without Automation Will Fall Behind

The industry is shifting. Borrowers demand digital experiences. Competitors increasingly use automation. New brokers enter the market with ready-made systems.

Manual brokers will appear slow, inconsistent and unresponsive by comparison.

Automation is no longer optional—it is the baseline standard for modern brokerages.